Aladdin Central Messageboard

Post a reply

Username

Subject

Guest post code

Who is the main character of "Aladdin"?

Message body

Emoticons





View more Emoticons

Font colour: Font size:

Close Tags

[quote="Mariposa79"][quote="Magdaleina"]There's a major difference between making a city, like Agrabah (not to mention Getzistan and Quarkistan) and centering their events in that area, and then making a city and twisting history around (without parody) to fit the story.

Cleopatra and Caesar were figures that Genie conjured. I mean, think about it; Moses was there, too, when he was doing that whole thing.

Also, Mechanikles is greek. Hence his title "Greatest of the Great Greek Geniuses". Yes, Rome and Greece existed at that point in time. However, the empire was not yet what it became later.

I'm sticking with what I said about the name. There's no reason why there would be a city in Egypt with an Indian name.

Also, I'm not denying this is something you made up. However, I'm doing what most serious writers and critics do; I'm analyzing what I've seen so far and constructively criticizing.

Was there a reason for quoting your post three times or was that a message board error?[/quote]
 
Message Board Error

It depends on your motive as a critic and the constructive criticism that you implore out.

Sometimes constructive criticism can be discouraging. That's why I so feel embarassed posting any of the pictures or stories here. I'm afraid that someone is going to run me out and make writing not so fun for me anymore. Does it have to be 100 % accurate based on history? Disney didn't really do their research on the historical events and timing in the original movie in Aladdin. That's why there's alot of confusion on what time period it actually is and when where what happened that goes in between.
So, why does mine have to be based upon accuracy?

Sorry, I just had to say that. Rajan ancestry was something that was made up last minute in this thread this afternoon. That whole entirety was made up because someone asked. Gosh?! do you really have to bust me for making up things as I go?  You go figure out where he got the eyes from. From now on my answer is that the Prince Rajan won the genetic lottery. Somewhere down his family line has blue eyes. This story, "Come What May" was one of my first fics. Did you actually took the time to read my story ? In my story, I didn't tell where Maharajah is at or how Rajan came to be. He was a prince who was arranged to be married to Jasmine.  
Knowing that she's married to Aladdin. His father and Rajan came to Agrabah to claim what's rightfully theirs.

From now, I will have depth in character development in my story.

In other words, NO I AM NOT CHANGING THE NAME OF THE CITY IN MY STORY. because the reason why I put that city name ties in why Jasmine got Rajah and name her tiger Rajah.[/quote]

Options
HTML is ON
BBCode is ON
Smilies are ON

	Disable HTML in this post
	Disable BBCode in this post
	Disable Smilies in this post